15-year-old golf phenom Alexis Thompson may sue LPGA to play on women’s tour
Alexis Thompson may sue the LPGA if the women’s professional golf tour does not waive its age requirement and let the 15-year-old phenom play as a member in 2011.
Distant option. Legal action against the LPGA “is only a far-off distant option,” Bobby Kreusler, Thompson’s manager at Blue Giraffe Sports, told Waggle Room in October. “We have to see how the situation progresses.”
Thompson, who turned pro this year and will be 16 in February, won $336,472 in six LPGA events she played with sponsors’ exemptions. Arguing that her winnings would place Thompson 29th on the LPGA money list, Kreusler said his client would likely petition the tour for 2011 membership.
LPGA regs allow non-members to apply for affiliation if they finish as top-80 money makers, a criterion Thompson easily met. She does not, however, qualify under the rule that requires members to be at least 18 years old.
Exceptions prove the rule? Exceptions to that prohibition allowed Morgan Pressel, Aree Song, and other under-18 amateurs to gain eligibility at LPGA Qualifying School. Thompson’s request would differ significantly, Kreusler argued, because of her professional status.
Thompson’s quest was “absolutely totally different,” said Kreusler. “Lexi easily earned enough money to earn a full card.”
Kreusler also believes Thompson deserved commissioner Michael Whan’s blessing, which he may grant to golfers between 15-years-old and 18 if they prove they meet their “professional and financial responsibilities,” according to tour bylaws.
Ready to play. With her LPGA playing partners attesting to Thompson’s competitive, social, and emotional grit, it was clear she was ready to play, said Kreusler.
“If Lexi can’t satisfy those criteria,” he observed, “I don’t know who could.”
Limited schedule. Another determining factor may be Thompson’s plans to play only 17 or so events next year. The home-schooled high school sophomore wants time to participate in homecoming and other activities typical of a 15-year-old girl, Kreusler said.
While Thompson had yet to file an official petition by Thanksgiving, Kreusler wanted the issue finalized before the end of 2010.
“We have talked [with the LPGA] early in the year,” said Kreusler. “We are entering into a more formal stage of how we will progress and/or if we will seek legal action.”
LPGA officials, who must privately yearn for the attention the long-hitting American star would bring to the tour, had no knowledge of a potential lawsuit.
“I had not heard that,” Heather Daly-Donofrio, LPGA director of media relations, told Waggle Room.
Each petition unique. Noting that each petition was unique, Daly-Donofrio said the tour could not address Thompson’s issues until it received the request.
"It was great to have Lexi with us on Tour for several events this season,” she said. “She played well, endeared herself to the fans and demonstrated that she has a bright future in professional golf. Whether she is ready at such an early age is a decision that will ultimately be made by Commissioner Whan."
Hectic travel plans. In the meantime, Thompson will earn a golf bag full of frequent-flyer miles in the next several months. She was scheduled to play at next month’s Omega Dubai Ladies Masters in the United Arab Emirates the Australian Women’s Open in February, and the ANZ Ladies Masters in Australia in March.
To stay in competitive shape, Thompson has played in local men’s tourneys like the recent Minor League Golf Tour event in Florida, in which she finished in a three-way tie for second. The only woman in the field, Thompson teed off from about 6,800-yard yards compared with the men’s 7,100 yards, and fell a birdie putt short of forcing a playoff with winner David Schuster.
Won’t mimic Wie. Kreusler stressed that Thompson played such events to “hone her skills for her next event,” and that she would not follow Michelle Wie’s much-criticized footsteps to the PGA Tour.
Thompson also appeared to be driving down a different fairway from that of another highly touted amateur, Mariah Stackhouse. The 16-year-old Georgia native, whom the American Junior Golf Association recently tapped as the first African American to serve on its board as the 2011 player representative, has said she planned to go to college following her stellar amateur career.
Talented youth. Win for win, it’s difficult to distinguish between Thompson and Stackhouse, who was the sole amateur (and favorite of @TheChristinaKim) in the LPGA’s inaugural Mojo 6 event earlier this year, and sits 19th in the Polo Golf Rankings.
In 2007, at the age of 12, Thompson was the youngest golfer to qualify for the U.S. Women’s Open. That year, she also won the Aldila Junior Classic and was the youngest player to win the Junior PGA Championship.
Though she missed the cut at the 2008 U.S. Women’s Open (as she did the year before), Thompson earned the U.S. Girls Junior Amateur title. The following year, she was South Atlantic Ladies Amateur champ and low amateur at the LPGA’s Kraft Nabisco Championship and made the cut at the Women’s Open.
Thompson turned pro immediately after posting a 4-0-1 record in the 2010 U.S. Curtis Cup and leading her team to victory. She notched three top-20 finishes this year, including a T2 at the Evian Masters.
Stackhouse stacks up. How does Stackhouse stack up (c’mon; you knew that was coming)? At 13, she was the youngest player to win the Georgia State Women’s Match Play title in 2007 and successfully defended her title the next season. She earned the Women’s State Amateur championship in 2009 and ’09. Stackhouse’s record and honors could fill a book, but you may check them out on her website.
Thompson, by the way, had three top-20 finishes this year, including a T2 at the Evian Masters.
-- Emily Kay
FanPosts are written by Waggle Room members. Viewpoints expressed do not necessarily reflect those of WaggleRoom.com, editor, Charles Boyer or any other writer or member.
21 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
This appears to be a good analysis to the situation, Emily. Thanks.
On a case-by-case basis, I think Lexi has proven her point. She deserves a card based on her earnings last year.
"(I)f you think you've got an inside track to absolute truth, you become doctrinaire, humorless and intellectually constipated." Saul Alinsky
The $336k that she earned is not all official money. I think I read a little while back that only about $27k of it would actually be considered as “official” towards getting a card by the money list. Not much they can do about that. Limited fields, US Open, and tournaments not on US soil don’t count.
I can’t tell you how disappointed I am with this whole situation. Less than 6 months ago, when Lexi declared her professional status, she and her family and Blue Giraffe were adamant that they were in no rush to join the LPGA and had no intentions of petitioning for an exception to the age rule.
How are you supposed to believe what Kreusler says when it seems to change from month to month ?
Since when do home schooled kids have homecoming and prom ? (and would she be homecoming and prom queen AND king at the dance ? Does she go out and find a match to play with another home schooled kid as her homecoming game ?)
How in the world did Mariah Stackhouse get into this conversation ? She had a great year on the state amateur level when she was 13, but hasn’t exactly been tearing up the amateurs since then. Her appearance with the pros was fun , but a complete mystery unless you buy into the “let’s get a minority amateur in the field” idea.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it." - Frederic Bastiat
Why the need
to threaten, no matter how remotely, to sue the LPGA? Let the girl go through due process in applying for an exemption before any legal threats are bandied about. Not exactly a good way to endear yourself to those in charge, especially so, when so much was made of her decision, not to seek an exemption earlier this year.
17 events is a full schedule, or close enough, so you can kiss goodbye any further education once she cards that magic card. It’s a pity that her advisors can’t seem to see past the dollar signs. Does anyone else get a “Wiesy” feeling about all this? The girl is 15 years old for goodness sake!
that’s what lawyers do – and lawyers are what agents generally are or are very close to.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it." - Frederic Bastiat
And that is to me, what is sad about this. Can anyone tell me honestly that a 15 year old, I know 16 in February should become a carpetbagging touring pro at that age? I know what is involved and how difficult it is, to do what she is contemplating as an adult. Why did Lorena and Annika ultimately retire at early ages? Because they had had enough of the travel and all that goes with it and they wanted a normal life. She may well be the best thing since sliced bread and what the Tour needs, but ultimately, at whose expense? There is a very good reason that the LPGA have the rule in place, but rules are seemingly made to be sued into submission. I hope that whatever happens, that Lexi is happy and has a chance at being the person she wants to be, not just the golfer she wants to be.
You’ll get different answers from different parts of the world. In the US, most of the time the answer is “no way Jose” (ignore the illegal alien overtone, please) :-)
Then again, Matteo Manassero posted a 3rd, 2nd, and a 1st this year. Ryo Ishikawa has a handful of wins on the Japan tour (regardless of how minor league the tour might be, professional wins aren’t like winning the local muni scramble) Kids in other sports around the world turn pro very young.
What would be nice is if the Thompsons and other families like them would take just half a step back and look at all the potential careers that were ruined by trying to take on the biggest guns too early, and realizing that these rules are there for a reason.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it." - Frederic Bastiat
YEA BUT !!!!!
Court, Chip, you both miss one very crucial point…it’s not the Kid, or the parents who are calling the shots…..IT’S THE SLICK WILLY MARKETING AGENTS (see companies here) that are and have been for years, running the show…And that’s in all professional sports….
I’m not going to get into a spitting contest here, other than to say that they don’t really give one of Wendys Flying Figs about the Kid….IT’S ALL ABOUT THE MONEY.
These sports promoters would sell their souls to the devil for enough loot. And have. I know, I know…the Kid and parents can’t get those high priced endorsements by themselves….They need to pay someone 25% of income….Court, your right….All the money reported here, doesn’t count as OFFICIAL MONEY.
I was hoping that there was a calm brain somewhere in that family…(see what parents are supposed to do for their children, not exploit) that would let a 15 year old, be that…A 15 year old, not a cash cow…..Just shows whats really important in this life doesn’t it…..sorry about this whole mess…just another poke in the eye with a sharp stick for the ladies tour…..STUB
We had both said that earlier (in another thread on Lexi). While you’re right that the marketing people are all about the Benjamins, they are also ultimately just representatives employed by the Thompsons. If the Thompsons don’t like something Blue Giraffe is doing, they can overrule them or fire them.
Had a thought yesterday – wondering if this is media spin – substituting the word “sue” for the word “petition”. One is a legal process, the other is the usual starting place between player and tour.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it." - Frederic Bastiat
I'm with Wendy...I think that makes more sense
Why sue anyone before going the normal route…And Court, Lest I forget, I do share yur pain on them JAWGA DAWGS…sorry bro… I agree that the parents can fire or override the Blue Giraffe, but I sense this is more of the twisted thinking that is so prevalent these days….Get all you can, while you can…We haven’t heard too much on theparents…how they are doing financially, with out the kids money…what does her dad do?, etc, etc….It costs a lot of money to play those Jr. tours….STUB
Her brother, Nicholas,
is a PGA Tour member, so the family know all about the life/travel
ups & downs of a professional golf player. Her other brother, Curtis, has also won on the amateur tour.
Legal action...
Brings change and evolution, its not al together a negative process in a democracy.
"If it doesn't work, you are trying to hard."
http://twitter.com/Roy_Ko
we don’t live in a democracy (thank goodness) and if you think that legal action to benefit one person that will set a precedent is always a good thing – then President Barry says “vote as often as you can” (except it’s hard to understand with that fat lip he got on the basketball court – ouch !! – that looked painful)
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it." - Frederic Bastiat
spoke with Blue Giraffe today...
….I know you’re going to wish you had sat down before reading this, but once again, the media got it wrong.
The Thompsons and Blue Giraffe are not suing the LPGA – they are petitioning and proposing a different kind of membership exemption than the standard “excuse me sir, may I play on the tour ?” petition they usually see.
They aren’t meeting with the LPGA until Tuesday, so he couldn’t give me any details, but I’ll know more later in the week.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it." - Frederic Bastiat
Sloppy reporting then.
Or just sensationalising to get your story read. Either way, no I’m not surprised.
whew – I’m glad to hear that – didn’t want to think that anyone would be shocked and hurt themselves fainting. :-)
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it." - Frederic Bastiat
I'm witcha Chip...
way too young…still lots of time to think of such crass things as making lots of money…..STUB

by 










