Waggle Room: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: The Record of Wrongs: Vanderbilt Commodores

Cog Hill Reminded Me Why I Like 2009 Tiger Better Than The '00 Model

After Woods began to work with Hank Haney, Tiger didn't stop winning at the same pace he had when working with Butch Harmon.  He won 32 titles with Butch between 1999 and 2003.  With Haney, he has won 31 times with one event remaining on the Tour schedule to tie the five year tally with Harmon. 

For all of the talk about Woods' performance in the majors this year - which was awfully good by almost any measure except Woods' own standard - he has won just one less major in the five years since the Haney changes kicked in versus at his best with Butch.  Since, Harmon has been rejected by Adam Scott and Ernie Els, and left Phil Mickelson in as much of a state of flux as could be possible for the third best golfer in the world.  Woods has had the last laugh in that battle.

Harmon would retort that Woods wins differently today than he did when they were the best of pals.  That's true.  Woods doesn't play golf tournaments like the godless killing machine that vanquished foes with little remorse and on a grand scale. 

The lack of remorse has been replaced with a sense of empathy, as evidenced by how he felt after his duel with Paddy Harrington in Akron. 

The grandiose wins have been replaced by ho-hum victories by one to four shots.  The wins pile up, but they don't have quite the same feel to them.  Woods rarely has an absolute victory these days.  Winning going away is a rarity.  Perhaps that is because Woods has no statements left to make in these run-of-the-mill Tour events.  For God's sake, he has won 71 of these things in 252 starts.  It is a formality that he will overtake Sam Snead's record for Tour wins.

While people like me lament that Woods 3.0 isn't nearly as dominante, this Tiger is more sophisticated.  He has more shots in the bag.  They were on full display at Cog Hill, and he has compiled a highlight reel of great escapes this season.  Perhaps that bag of tricks was borne out of his wild driver - the one club he seems incapable of taming.  In some sense, it is more impressive that Tiger wins at approximately the same pace despite not putting the pedal to the medal in every tournament. 

To some extent, Tiger 3.0 is more exciting than the Terminator.  This Tiger keeps it close.  He makes it exciting.  There are more opportunities for a Rocco, or a Yang, or a Slocum.  What happened at Hazeltine never would have happened to 2000 Tiger Woods.  And, you know what, I'm glad that those guys had their shot at Tiger.  Since the supposed Big Three or Five or anybody else that's purportedly really great can't do it, someone had to step up and mar the record of the greatest golfer ever.  In the midst of golf's Lost Generation, Woods has no equal except some middling pro on an idle Sunday for Tiger. 

Were it not for this version of Tiger, we never would have seen Woods slam his hat in a black out celebration at Bay Hill.  Nor would we have seen him repeat the feat in the darkness one year later.  The old Tiger would have won by five or ten.  Yeah, those days were awesome and all, but I kind of like this Tiger better.

The guy is a freakin' billionaire and has made hundreds of other less talented players into instant millionaires because of his play.  He deserves to ride on cruise control every now and then, especially coming off of knee surgery and a rapid rehab.  Ernie Els is still trying to recover from knee surgery - at least in Tiger's view.  It has been three years.  In one comeback season, Woods has double the number of PGA Tour wins that Ernie Els has around the world in the entire duration of his comeback.

Let's not forget that this is only the third season in Tiger's professional career in which he has not won a major title.  But do remember that Woods way vying to win a major in five consecutive years.  No one had ever done that, much less doing so in the fifth year coming off of a knee surgery and accompanying swing changes.  For as hard as we are on the guy to say that he may have lost a step, we have to recall that he literally could not walk this time last year and he still almost won the PGA Championship.  That would be like if Barbaro had come back from his ankle injury to win the Kentucky Derby the next year.  And Barbaro isn't racing anymore - in case you haven't heard.

Despite my love for the modern Tiger, it was nice to see a throwback.  It is heartening to know that the old Tiger is lurking somewhere inside and, when he needs it, he can bring it back.  Now after a span of two weeks in flux - a time frame that seemed like eons ago - Woods will be re-elevated to the highest of his career peaks.  With his closest competition in the form of the steady Jim Furyk and determined Steve Stricker, Woods will get a good final test in what he calls one of his best seasons. 

0 recs  |  Comment 6 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Around SB Nation

Super Commercials

Feb 2010 from Front Office Fans - 4 comments

Comments

Display:

Old vs New Tiger

What was nice to see this weekend, especially on Sunday, was Tiger having fun on the golf course. Never before had I seen him smile more and look like he was actually happy. Granted, he had a 7-shot lead, but if that is what it takes for him to show some positive emotion as opposed to throwing his club in a bush, then I am all for it.

Adam Fonseca

by ChicagoDuffer on Sep 14, 2009 2:41 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

That’s true. Terminator Tiger does have more fun. Then again, Tiger at the ’08 US Open seemed to be having a lot of fun in that amazing third round back nine.

Email me any comments or questions at ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com.

by Ryan Ballengee on Sep 14, 2009 2:57 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

you missed one

“the godless killing machine that vanquished foes with little remorse and on a grand scale.” LMAO – I love it.

A couple of things about Butch Harmon – he oversaw Tiger’s swing through versions 1 and 2. In 1, he was playing like a kid in a candy store – looking for birdies on every tee box. He started with a 68 on his card, assuming that par 5’s were birdie holes.

Version 2, Butch slowed him down a bit – taught him a lot of shots and a lot more efficiency. He played fewer tournaments – bulked up – and used his mind more than pure physical talent.

Version 3 you mentioned – a switch between Harmon and Haney – more streamlining – more intimidation – more intelligence…except with the driver.

Then came the knee surgery and in version 4, we’re seeing him adust even more to protect the knee – even to the point of…say it quietly…hitting fairways with the driver and staying in better balance. We don’t see as many miracle shots and chip ins and insane flop shots like we did in version 1 – but we get shots like we saw on Saturday from behind a tree in 4" of rough hit to flag high on a tucked pin.

The scary thing is, he has 6 wins with one more tournament left – he smells $10 million – and that’s fresh meat on the jungle floor. He is still getting into the flow of the new swing. What will he do next year when he’s 100% and in even better control ?

I like that there are a few guys out there who have shown that they are going to play Tiger hard – two actually beat him this year. (Yang and Slocum) Now if we could just get the younger guys to give up the hero worship and show him what they can do – challenge the “old man”.

Easy on the “rejection” talk about Els, Scott, and Mickelson. All three got a lot out of Harmon, and Butch doesn’t contract with players like most of these other coaches. All of his students are free to come and go as they like…as long as they are ready to work.

"this ball will fit in that fairway"

by courtgolf on Sep 14, 2009 5:22 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I don’t think the Terminator is gone. Let’s not forget that Tiger didn’t expect to win as quickly as he did, coming off the knee surgery. I don’t care how Tiger complains about how he’s playing well but just isn’t scoring, or how many commentators say that this year isn’t up to Tiger’s standards (how they know what those standards are is beyond me) — I bet Tiger is pleased beyond belief at how well he’s played this year. If Ernie Els had had this kind of year after his knee surgery, he’d probably still be #2.

A lot of the other pros have finally realized that they don’t have to beat Tiger at his own game to win; they just have to play their own game well. I’m glad they’re finally giving him a little competition.

But you mark my words: After the President’s Cup, after Tiger’s had an off-season to recharge his batteries and just play with his kids for a while, do you know what you’re going to see next year?

One of those freakin’ silver shapeshifting Terminators… but it will be the headliner playing the part, not the supporting cast. And then we’ll see how much the other Tour players have really learned about playing against the Big Cat.

Mike Southern
www.ruthlessgolf.com

by Ruthless Mike on Sep 14, 2009 5:56 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Not so fast!
The lack of remorse has been replaced with a sense of empathy, as evidenced by how he felt after his duel with Paddy Harrington in Akron.

He may have felt bad for Paddy AFTER the WGC was over, but didn’t he stuff his eight iron for 182 yards to a couple feet and tap in for birdie while Paddy was throwing up all over himself? And then birdie the 18th for good measure?

He beat Paddy by five strokes on the final 3 holes and still smiled when they handed him the trophy.

Tiger’s mindset is still to dominate and step on the throat of his competition. It’s no different than what Jordan, Federer & Ali tried to do. He plays more conservatively now, but it’s in no way reflective of a kinder, gentler Tiger. He still wants to accomplish the same goal, he just tries to do so with less risk.

by MattSpence on Sep 15, 2009 7:35 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I think that’s a good point to distinguish that I mean empathy AFTER the beating – not during.

Email me any comments or questions at ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com.

by Ryan Ballengee on Sep 15, 2009 12:47 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Waggle Room! Join our community! Have a golf story tip? Contact editor Ryan Ballengee and he will follow the story.
Start posting on Waggle Room »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Breaking down the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am celebrities
Small
Tom Watson is a 60 year old stud
Tiger_and_the_magic_club_small
Are you ready for the Mojo 6 ?
Adam2_small
Hyler Instated As USGA's 61st President
Cat_small
Hana Bank Returns as Sponsor on 2010 LPGA Schedule
Small
Golf Styles I'm Still Undecided On
Images_3_small
Some real help for golf blogists with brain damage
Adam2_small
Tiger Out of Rehab; Elin Staying Put
Golfmoolah_app_homepage_small
Who Thinks it's still COOL to yell "it's in the hole" anymore?
Adam2_small
Now This is What I'm Talking About!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Golf News Net Shows

The 19th Hole Golf Show - 1/29 - This week's 19th Hole Golf Show features one of my favorite golf writers, Jason Sobel from ESPN. I recap my visit to the PGA Show in Orlando - the good and the bad.  Also, we touch on the Doug Barron situation and the Desert Swing event in Doha, Qatar this weekend.

Listen NOW on the Golf News Net Media Player!

The 19th Hole Golf Show on iTunes

GNN Newsmakers Feed

The 19th Hole Golf Show






Managers

Ryan2_small Ryan Ballengee