Waggle Room: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Post-UNC Thoughts

What I Think Golf on TV is Missing

Today is a slow news day, so I was trying to poke around the Series of Tubes to see if anything struck my creative nerves.  Rudy Giuliani's son?  Nah.  He's an idiot.  Byron Nelson?  Haven't played enough yet.  What should be included in a golf telecast?  That's the one.

The Shop Blog at golf.com by David Dusek poses an interesting question:

Does anyone think that equipment news/features could enhance TV coverage of golf events?

The answer to this question and any one like it is simple.  The people that put golf on television should provide the viewer with everything that they can do so that the fan can understand what the pro is doing, why they're doing it, and how they're doing it.

In summer 2006, I wrote a long column really nailing CBS Sports on their coverage of golf.  I scoured the archives over at Golf News Net to find it.

Basically, my gripes with CBS (and golf on TV in general) were:

  • Too many factual errors on the telecast
  • Not liking some commentators - everyone has those people that grate them
  • Way too much focus on Tiger - it's worse now

My suggestion, though, to improve the telecasts then remains the same today.  Golf tournaments tell a story of a course, players, and a title.  To tell that story is more than just showing golf shots and leaderboards. 

Star-divide

It is explaining why golfers make the decisions that they do on course.  This includes a lot of the technology we use today.  Fly-overs, Google graphics, and imagery to show where players should hit the ball and when not to be too aggressive.

It is also detailing the differences in how players approach a course.  That means talking about the equipment that the players use and how they are able to customize it to suit their game.  The fan should know that a player intends to hit 5 wood off of the 13th tee, but why not use a 2 iron instead? 

I don't care that much what a player does off of the course as much as I care about what they're doing on it.  Yes, that includes showing emotion - or at least proving you're not the Golfbot 6000.

A golfer may appear to win or lose a golf tournament on one hole and, in some cases, they actually do.  More often than not, though, golfers win tournaments by consistent performance over a stretch of holes - maybe as few as six but could be the whole week. 

Henrik Stenson outplayed all of his opponents on the front side of The Players Championship

Show me that as he is strolling up 18 with an impressive win.

If Anthony Kim catches fire on Saturday and moves from 58th place all the way up to 9th in five holes, I want to see that while the leaders are moseying along the course.  Maybe a graphic like this:

Mockgraphic_medium

Again, the whole idea behind broadcasting a tournament is to tell the full story.  TV is doing better with AimPoint, the shot trackers, and the X-Mo swing shots.  But we also need to see how players move through the course and the field to their ultimate result.

0 recs  |  Comment 6 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I really like the idea of using the graphics to show “best positions” for shots. For the most part, they do a pretty good job at showing the problems/advantages they have where the ball already lies. The only drawback to the graphics is…as always…Johnny Miller and his arrogance. He would use this as another tool to tell people how great a shot HE would play and if this guy doesn’t hit the ball to the blade of grass Miller would hit it, Miller will go on yet another rant on how great he was compared to players of today.

We differ a bit on the emotion issue. Emotions are fine, but who decides what emotions are acceptable ? Tiger shows emotion with the fist pumps and attempts at high 5’s with Steve – but he also swears and slams clubs – that’s emotion – but when he, or any other player, does it, he gets reemed for the negative – followed by the cliche “he needs to control those emotions so he won’t get too high or too low”…yada yada yada. I don’t care that Henrik Stenson fits the mold of the stoic Swede – I care that he hits amazing golf shots.

One of the best things I like about the Euro Tour broadcasts is the opening of the show when they take you to points of interest in the area – then they get to the leaderboard. I’m with you – I don’t care about all these little vignets that interrupt showing shots….but that is a part of the feminization of sports. Women want the little stories and the emotional bits and pieces around the game. When I was a kid, it was all about the game and I wish we could get back to that – but it isn’t going to happen. (I can barely watch the Olympics anymore because of this stuff)

Show me the game – let me listen in on the player/caddy conversation in a tough situation or coming down the stretch. Show me the hole with the trouble and correct places to play. I like the Shot Tracer, and sort of like the putter tracker (until Kelly Tilghman starts trying to get in on the act). I like the laser measuring of shots – but I REALLY doubt the accuracy on the greens. The announcers say that a putt is 8’ out – but they make the putt and take ones step to the hole ? That’s a mighty long stride. (How in the world did Suzanne Pettersen miss a “3’ putt” at 16 the other day when all she had to do was turn her left foot and reach into the hole. If she was 3’ away, she would have taken at least a step to get to the hole. If that putt was more than 18", I’d be shocked – looked more like a foot)

I really think they could make better use of recorded shots to show more action. Instead of showing 5 minutes of Tiger lining up a putt or deciding if it’s a stock wedge to the green or a full wedge or a nuked wedge (just hit the damn shot). Use the recorders to cover shots from more than just the guys in the last group. We don’t know – we’re not there – just show more shots.

"this ball will fit in that fairway"

by courtgolf on May 21, 2009 1:18 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Very well said. It really wouldn’t be that difficult to jazz it all up without going silly on it. It appears sometimes the telecasters lack imagine when covering golf.

by AussieGolfer on May 21, 2009 9:09 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

So many things on TV are personality driven these days – that’s why Bill O’Reilly is popular. Really, though, the best commentators should rarely be a part of the story. The tournament is the story and whatever can be done to tell it better would be great!

Email me any comments or questions at ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com.

by Ryan Ballengee on May 21, 2009 10:37 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I agree there may be excessive coverage on

Tiger. I can live with reduced TW coverage as long as they still at least get him walking onto the first tee, being introduced and hitting his drive. And every single shot of his until he putts out on eighteen. It is also imperative we are able to view him walking to his ball between shots. Naturally, his preshot routine cannot be cut out, especially with his 360 degree evaluation of the putting surface before he actually addresses his putt.

I do think it is excessive to show him just standing whispering to Stevie while his fellow-competitor, Alex Cejka is lining up his putt for a final round 79.

by One-Eyed Golfer Guy on May 22, 2009 9:38 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I really do enjoy the mic’d up caddy-player convos. But only do it when the trophy is really on the line. Though, I admit that it would be funny to hear a player and caddy talking about the “talent” in the crowd.

Email me any comments or questions at ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com.

by Ryan Ballengee on May 22, 2009 9:54 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

lol – that would have to be a pay-per-view broadcast

"this ball will fit in that fairway"

by courtgolf on May 22, 2009 10:05 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Waggle Room! Join our community! Have a golf story tip? Contact editor Ryan Ballengee and he will follow the story.
Start posting on Waggle Room »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Golf News Net Shows

The 19th Hole Golf Show - 11/4 - We start the show by discussing the HSBC Champions and LPGA Mizuno Classic.  Then we talk with top 100 teacher Charlie King about how he plans to change golf instruction.  And, finally, we talk with legendary golfer Tom Watson about a host of subjects, including Turnberry.

Listen NOW on the Golf News Net Media Player!

The 19th Hole Golf Show on iTunes

GNN Newsmakers Feed

GNN MP3 Players

The 19th Hole Golf Show

Waggle Room Media

Facebook, Twitter, & Podcasts - Oh My!






Managers

Ryan2_small Ryan Ballengee