Charles Howell III: Choke Artist or Unmotivated Rich Guy?

While I was out playing golf on Sunday afternoon, I did catch a lot of video of the final round of the Zurich Classic of New Orleans. Jerry Kelly wound up picking up his first win in seven years on the PGA Tour and it couldn't have happened to a nicer guy. But, I cannot help but be taken aback - again - by Charles Howell III's inability to close out a golf tournament. The Twitter-obsessed golf.com roundtable discussed the topic:
Shipnuck: Jerry Kelly is one of the good guys and this will be a popular win in the locker room, press room and caddie yard. But to me the real story is Charles Howell letting a tournament get away for the third time this year. I think he's too nice a guy for tournament golf. I hope he's somewhere trashing a hotel room. If you do it once it means you care. If you do it monthly, it means you're Daly.
Morfit: The thing that struck me about Kelly's win was how much of the Tour is a mind game. It's painful to watch Charles Howell try to close out a tournament. He's obviously very talented, and a nice guy, but man, something is way off between the ears. That par putt on 17 was pitiful, and the birdie effort on 18 was only slightly better. The only time that guy looked like a serious player was when he beat Phil at Riviera a few years back.
Interestingly enough, the roundtable then kind of gets on an aside about why CH3 struggles as he does to win. The speculation turns into a discussion of how pros from well off backgrounds don't seem to do as well on the PGA Tour.
Lipsey: Talent doesn't make a champion. Needing it does. Growing up with money isn't an automatic disqualifier, but it's a hurdle to overcome. Howell, the son of a successful doctor, has all the talent but apparently not much need.
Hack: Are you saying you don't think Charles is hungry enough? I respectfully disagree. If anything, he's been overdoing it, trying to figure out his game. The guy works out, beats a million balls, and works hard. I don't think the fact that his dad is a surgeon has anything to do with flying a 90-yard wedge shot over the green.
Most of the crew comes to the conclusion that Rick Lipsey is wrong in the case of CH3 because of how hard he practices. In fact, they come to the conclusion that maybe he wants it too bad and is overdoing it to get wins. (And I came to the conclusion that Rick Lipsey either really likes being blunt and wrong, or just likes being wrong.)
We have talked on here quite a bit about how we feel that the younger players really seem to be content by finishing top 5 and making six figures for losing. Perhaps, though, there are pockets of young players that actually are hyperdriven to win but cannot bust through the glass ceiling. The intrigue in CH3 is that he was a fantastic college player. He learned what it took to win in the NCAA ranks yet he struggles mightily to even win the New Orleans event. Meanwhile, in the right moment, he stared down an admittedly weak Mickelson performance at Riviera a few years ago.
I'm still not sure what to make of CH3 who has probably had more opportunities to win golf tournaments than a lot of his contemporaries. What does it say about a guy who has a lot of chances to win if his peers often never even get that close?
ADD ON: The Golf Watch has Frank Nobilo's thoughts on what CH3 should do now. Turn off everything and just play golf.
0 recs |
5 comments
|
Comments
Guess what – they ALL could be right – and NONE of their analyses would get CH into the winner’s circle. Yes – he is extraordinarily talented physically and mechanically. Yes – put my opinion in this box, too – his focus on mechanics has caused him to not learn how to handle pressure down the stretch when he needs solid nerves to make shots. Yes – he is a nice guy, and some nice guys don’t have that killer instinct.
I have said for years that anybody that spends a lot of time as a professional with Leadbetter will never become a winner because all you work on are the beginner’s basics. He is a swing mechanic better suited for people just learning the game than a pro who needs to work between the ears.
I was thrilled with the coverage yesterday when Gary McCord and Peter Kostis got into a discussion of Howell’s putting statistics and concentration on mechanics. McCord pointed out that through most of his career, Howell has been ranked 140 or worse in Tour putting stats. You can’t win if you can’t putt – or maybe he just doesn’t hit enough shots close enough to the flag.
McCord asked Kostis what he would do if Howell was one of his students. Kostis said he would take him out and put him behind trees and bushes and buried in bunkers and all kinds of impossible places to MAKE him learn how to be creative and how to get out of tough spots.
"this ball will fit in that fairway"
by courtgolf on Apr 27, 2009 12:06 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
That’s a very good point. CH3 is way too technical for his own good. I have always found that people I play with struggle mightily when they get too technical. I have a swing that I’m pretty happy with and it is easy to remember. There are like five things that can go wrong with it and, since I know them, I can play with feel right out of the box. Yesterday, took one practice swing on the first tee and played well enough to get into the 70s had I a better short game. (The first thing to go.) CH3 definitely has to get to that place.
by Ryan Ballengee on Apr 27, 2009 12:17 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
The guy was freakin...what? 6 under or 7 under for the day
at one point?
He came back from 4 down to take the lead and only shot 2 over the last 4-5 holes…which is far from terrible
Why he putted the ball so hard on 17 when he could have just touched it is beyond me but….he didn’t really choke it, imo
by AppleCub on Apr 27, 2009 7:58 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Frank Nobilo's right on.
Keep plugging away.
by Cairo on Apr 27, 2009 8:53 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I can’t call him a choke artist because he keeps getting close. There’s a lot to be said for that since he actually wants to win and doesn’t settle after his failures.
Email me any comments or questions at ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com.
by Ryan Ballengee on Apr 27, 2009 9:36 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 













