Match Play A Sign of American Weakness?
This year, there are fewer Americans that made the field of the Accenture Match Play than ever. Only 17 Americans made the field. In the first round, golf.com tells us that Americans went 12-3 against players from other countries. (That means there was one match where an American had to lose.)
I have said before that Americans like watching other Americans. Many Americans could not care less about golfers from other countries. In fact, most only seem to care about one American in particular.
Stewart Cink was quoted in the golf.com piece:
"The number of Americans has gone down every year they've had the tournament. There are a lot of good players around the world, and a lot of World Ranking points going that direction."
That is about as netural of a statement as an American could make about the demise of the red, white, and blue from the highest ranks of golf. If you look at the quote closely enough, there's a hint that World Ranking points may be to blame for a "technical bounce" in the rankings of global players. Cink may have a point.
Take Lin Wen-Tang. He finished 2nd on the Asian Tour money list last year. He got whalloped in round one 7&5 by Anthony Kim. How about another Asian Tour star in Prayad Marksaeng? Ousted on day one by Lee Westwood.
Maybe the Asian Tour is overrated - in fact, I'm sure of it. Still, the youth of Europe are proving their worth in spades so far this week. Rory McIlroy, Ian Poulter, Luke Donald (yes, he's still young), Ross Fisher, and Oliver Wilson are all still alive with 16 players left.
Consider that South Africa is alive and well with Ernie Els and Tiger-slayer Tim Clark.
Of the sixteen players left, five are American. Two face each other today - Phil Mickelson and Stewart Cink. At best, four will get to the round of eight. If four make it, then half of the final eight will have their caddies donning the American flag on their bibs. That would help prove that Americans are still dominant in the game, despite there being fewer of them in this field than ever.
Then again, this is just one event. More telling, perhaps, is that only three players have won multiple majors in the last five years. Two of them are American, and one can still win this week. Phil Mickelson, the hopes and dreams of America may well rest on you.
0 recs |
4 comments
|
Comments
this is an argument I have never liked...
…Because the rest of the world is improving – that does not mean that Americans are getting weaker. The idea that a player from another country can’t possibly get good enough to make it into the top 64 is nonsense.
Using match play format to say that American golfers are weaker than non-American golfers is also not a strong argument. This format is used once a year on the PGA Tour and once a year on the European Tour, plus Ryder and Presidents Cup teams.
What has happened is that the game has gotten even bigger around the globe. Athletes who might have chosen soccer or some other professional sport have started playing golf because there is a lot of money to be made. When you expand the pool, it is natural for the concentration of players to spread out.
"this ball will fit in that fairway"
by courtgolf on Feb 27, 2009 4:20 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Completely agree. The world has gotten better, and there’s no doubt about it. I think my conclusion does agree with yours that match play doesn’t tell us that much. Tells us something, but not much. Two of the best three players in the world today are American. That shows we’re still dominant.
by Ryan Ballengee on Feb 27, 2009 4:37 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Toptenitis
How can American golfers expect to win at match play when for 51 weeks per year they don’t try to win at medal play? Somewhere in the early 1990’s, these guys saw you could make a very, very good living just making top tens. You kept your card, you qualified for all the majors and invitation events and it allowed you to not care too much if you missed 5-6 cuts per year. I think during tour rookie orientation, the new guys are lined up and given the toptenitis injection.
Most Americans do not actually lose at match play. They simply run out of holes trying to play one shot at a time, one hole at a time and one nice little check at a time…
by One-Eyed Golfer Guy on Mar 1, 2009 10:13 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
ouch
that’s a bit harsh. yes, there are SOME guys out there who are not driven to win – but to say that ALL OF THEM are that way…except for Tiger, of course.
Only 1 guy wins each week – even if 10 guys tie – only 1 gets the winner’s check after a playoff. There are only 36 opportunities to win, so it is more likely that you will NOT win in any given tournament over a year.
I’ll agree with you that these guys make a ton or money without winning, but to say that they don’t have any drive to win is ludicrous.
"this ball will fit in that fairway"
by courtgolf on Mar 2, 2009 11:13 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs

by 














