Rickie Fowler's Swing: We Ask Top Instructors
Coming off of his second place finish in a playoff at the Frys.com Open, everyone and their mother is ready to crown Rickie Fowler as golf's next Tiger Woods. Having nearly won as an amateur on the Nationwide Tour earlier this season didn't draw much attention, but his play in the Arizona desert turned a lot of heads.
(Curiously enough, there's not much talk about Jamie Lovemark - other than that he is the luckiest son of a bitch ever.)
But, haven't we heard enough cautionary tales of unproven young talents that we can draw on to stop ourselves from proclaiming Fowler as the next ultrastar billionaire in our sport?
Michelle Wie. Ty Tryon. Hal Sutton - at least in his 20s and 30s. Anthony Kim is in a big ole slump. Danny Lee didn't get out of round one of Q-school. Tadd Fujikawa. Care for me to continue?
Some of the above turned out to be late bloomers. Sutton made a late stage comeback to solidify his legacy.
Michelle Wie is still blooming, in search of that first LPGA Tour win. Danny Lee already won this year, but we haven't heard much since - including a miss in the first stage of PGA Tour Q-school.
Ty Tryon bloomed too soon. He isn't even playing golf these days after peaking early and buying too much into his own hype.
Don't crown Fowler as an immediate success. A runner-up is great, but he definitely had some flaws in his game this weekend. Despite massive length, his swing is very heavy on a lot of action. Think Sergio's swing before he tweaked it. But is that cause for concern?
Gary Gilchrist, head of the Gary Gilchrist Golf Academy, noted the similarities between Garcia and Fowler - and the trap Garcia entered.
"When you're playing well, you tend to look at weaknesses and how to get better. If you keep listening to the critics though, like Sergio did, then it can cost you."
Garcia was pronounced a phenom after his 1999 loss to Tiger Woods at the PGA Championship. And we all know how that has turned out since.
To date, though, Rickie's swing has held up very well. And it appears that the sentiment among the keenest eyes in the game is that it will continue to hold up under pressure. Gilchrist noted that Fowler's mechanics are not what makes him a strong player.
"Could [Fowler] swing on a better plane? Sure. But the swing is 10% of the game. Fowler has a swing he believes in and trusts. That's more important that a great, mechanical swing."
Renowned teacher Jim McLean weighed in, having personal experience in working with Rickie and his son, Jon, having been a teammate of Fowler's at Oklahoma State.
"I worked with Rickie one time, at the Porter Cup a few years ago when he was just a little bit off. One thing I told Rickie then was to not change his swing, and that I liked what he did," McLean said. "I also had high praise for his teacher in California."
McLean made an equally apt comparison to Fowler. In addition to Garcia, McLean compared Fowler's mechanics to that of Ryan Moore - a winner in Greensboro this season.
"I told the same to a young Ryan Moore and his father years ago when Ryan's dad asked me about working with his son or possibly making a swing change. Rickie has a similar type swing, but more standard than Ryan's.
"Rickie reminds me of a young Lanny Wadkins, one of the greatest ball strikers I have ever seen, and about the same size. Great swings in golf have a certain degree of abanonment. Most people do not recognize how crucial this is to top class golf. Rickie has that gift. My opinion is his swing will last. Hopefully some strong willed method teacher never gets into his head."
Talking to Tiger Woods' swing coach Hank Haney about Fowler's swing, he simply said, "If it was going to be unreliable it would have already been that way. He sure has done pretty good."
Fowler certainly has credentials. Having been recognized as the best college golfer in America as a freshman and nearly winning on the Nationwide Tour earlier this year, Fowler's body of work seems to validate the remarks and praise of all three teachers. Results speak for themselves.
Further, Fowler he has inherent talent inside of 100 yards. He has displayed a propensity to drain putts from anywhere and be very sharp with the wedges. If he can make the adjustment necessary to the new grooves next season, he could be lethal even with any faulty mechanics that could manifest themselves. Just ask Tiger what a great short game can compensate for on Tour.
Gary Gilchrist cautions any young player, though, against using Tiger as a standard for their swing.
"Don't learn how to be Tiger Woods," Gilchrist said. "Learn to be yourself."
Fowler clearly believes in himself, but that may just be part of the equation. The man that beat both he and Lovemark in the playoff was a journeyman who has been at his career best in the Fall Series. If Fowler could be bested by Troy Matteson, then perhaps there is still a little ways to go for him to reach his potential.
But, potential sure is exciting and the best swing eyes in the game are convinced that this is just the beginning for RIckie Fowler.
0 recs |
15 comments
|
Comments
The problem with any new young golfer...
…is the fact that Tiger is still running the table on Tour, and continues to improve. Nobody can be the “next Tiger Woods” until he actually stops winning or eventually plays on the Champions Tour. Setting these young guys up for greatness right now would be like saying some new baseball slugger is the next A-Rod. Legend is still being written.
Adam Fonseca
by ChicagoDuffer on Oct 26, 2009 6:29 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I thought about writing a long bit about that for this piece, but got such good stuff from Jim, Gary, and Hank that there was just no room for conjecture. They all actually changed my mind about Fowler’s swing. I was predisposed to think that it may not last long term. They all – echoing each other – convinced me otherwise.
Find me! Email: ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com, Twitter: http://twitter.com/waggleroomryan, or Facebook: http://facebook.com/waggleroom.
by Ryan Ballengee on Oct 26, 2009 6:47 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Good stuff
Love the analysis from top instructors. Haney’s particularly resonates — Fowler has come this far, so why think about trying to fix something that isn’t broken?
The same can be said for Matteson’s swing. His isn’t mechanically laudable either, yet he shook off the poor shot on 18 during regulation with one of the shots of the tournament (if only there hadn’t been so many holes in one and a double eagle) on the second playoff hole.
A similar case could even be made for Lovemark, who appears to stand closer to the ball at address than most.
Every PGA Tour pro has made bad swings under pressure (even Tiger, of course), but nobody knows their swings better than the players themselves, so unless they feel there’s a specific type of miss that’s happening too often when the chips are down, then they’ll probably stick with what they have. And that’s refreshing in today’s perceived cookie-cutter era of golf instruction.
Eli Miller
http://www.southlandgolfmagazine.com
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/millertimegolf
by SouthlandGolf on Oct 26, 2009 7:05 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
yeah – that Haney is a mechanical genius….when’s that Charles Barkley lesson series on again ? :-)
"this ball will fit in that fairway"
by courtgolf on Oct 26, 2009 7:18 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Hank Haney couldn’t fix Barkley, that’s for sure.
That’s like asking Mario Andretti to fix up a Chevy Aveo and run it in the Indy 500. It just wouldn’t work no matter how hard he tries.
by Old Man Par on Oct 27, 2009 8:35 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
not the WAY he was doing it – not a chance. Haney denied that the problem started in Barkley’s head. Until you get that fixed, the physical mechanics of the swing will never be fixed. I talked about it after the first episode when Haney laughed at Barkley’s story of what happened to his swing. You could see that it really bothered Barkley.
"this ball will fit in that fairway"
by courtgolf on Oct 27, 2009 9:56 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I thought the contrast of the three swings from the players in the playoff was really an interesting dynamic. One is stack and tilt, one is very mechanically savvy, and the other was Rickie Fowler’s freewheeling swing.
Find me! Email: ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com, Twitter: http://twitter.com/waggleroomryan, or Facebook: http://facebook.com/waggleroom.
by Ryan Ballengee on Oct 26, 2009 8:25 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Ya gotta admit, Court, that’s one tough hitch to scratch.
by TXQ on Oct 26, 2009 8:40 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
How soon we forget…
The concept of an “ideal swing” is pretty recent. Most of the legends of the game had swings that were, to be kind, “idiosyncratic.” We forget that Hogan’s swing was radical when he began to win with it, as was Jack’s and virtually every other great player. But success always convinces someone that there’s only one way to swing. (OK, Trevino didn’t get that kind of reaction, but his swing held up pretty well over his career, didn’t it?) Even Tiger gets constant criticism when he makes a change… until he proves it’ll work.
My point is this: I think every great player has something funky about his or her swing. That doesn’t mean that funkiness is an indicator of greatness; but if that funkiness either maximizes a strength or minimizes a weakness, that’s the kind of funkiness that can lead to greatness.
Rickie Fowler has a funky swing that apparently allows him to focus on playing golf, not just hitting certain positions. If it keeps working for him and he’s smart enough to stick with it, I don’t think I’d bet against him.
Mike Southern
www.ruthlessgolf.com
by Ruthless Mike on Oct 26, 2009 10:47 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
How was Jack’s swing radical? Everything I have ever read from the time describes his swing as “picture perfect.” Arnold Palmer’s swing, not so much, and many think that’s why Jack owned Palmer once he got his feet wet on the Tour. Same thing for Gary Player, BTW.
Then again, take a look at Charles Howell III’s swing. It’s a work of art but it hasn’t led him to the trophy in PGA events or majors many times. Golf at that level comes down to short game and putting if you are finding the fairways and have adequate distance and control.
by Old Man Par on Oct 27, 2009 8:38 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Mike – Bobby Jones’ had a swing technique called “The Carnoustie Swing”. There was also a St Andrews Swing. They were opposing swing theories dating back to the 19th century that both believed they were best. I’d bet there were others before then…and we know how things have gone since then.
I agree with you on Fowler…for now. He’s 21 and is still a rubber band – but we ALL know that by the age of 25, he’s going to go through a lot of physical changes that are going to make that tempo really difficult to keep. It’s going to be interesting to see how he handles the physical changes.
"this ball will fit in that fairway"
by courtgolf on Oct 27, 2009 10:01 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
We also have to remember that what the “right swing” was different in each era because of the impact equipment had.
Find me! Email: ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com, Twitter: http://twitter.com/waggleroomryan, or Facebook: http://facebook.com/waggleroom.
by Ryan Ballengee on Oct 27, 2009 9:29 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Lanny Wadkins ?
RB – did your ears perk up when McLean brought Lanny Wadkins and “ball striker” came into the conversation ? That’s another phrase that has a lot of definitions that you can never prove right or wrong.
Wadkins also had to go through a lot of swing changes after college that really helped, but took a long time to solidify in his game. He could hit the hell out of the ball – but he didn’t have a swing that could hold up under the strain of the PGA Tour until he knuckled down and made the changes.
"this ball will fit in that fairway"
by courtgolf on Oct 27, 2009 10:06 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
That sounds a lot like Sergio. If so, that’s bad news bears.
Find me! Email: ryan@thegolfnewsnet.com, Twitter: http://twitter.com/waggleroomryan, or Facebook: http://facebook.com/waggleroom.
by Ryan Ballengee on Oct 27, 2009 10:36 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Ty Tryon...
is still playing. He leads the 1st Stage of Q-School in Lakeland, FL after rounds of 71-62.
by short-sided on Oct 28, 2009 8:20 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 
















