Waggle Room: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: The Boxing Bulletin for Boxing Fans!

USGA Looking Into Limiting Wedge Lofts

We haven't really covered the story here at Waggle Room, but it is not a secret that the USGA is rumored to be looking into limiting wedge lofts.  The story was first brought up at the Bomb and Gouge blog at Golf Digest.  There's nothing official about it on USGA.org.

[T]he USGA will be conducting "research on high-lofted wedges. This research is being conducted to determine if high-lofted wedges (for example, 60 degrees of loft and higher) can reduce the challenge of the game for shots near the green."

The issue has drawn criticism from Geoff Shackelford and Tom Wishon - guys I just happen to agree with a lot on equipment issues.  Wishon was interviewed by The Examiner's Steve Pike for a sarcastic article on the proposed research.

"The USGA is wasting all sorts of time and money looking into the possibility of setting a limit for loft on wedges," he said. "There is no way loft can be a technology that replaces skill in the game, so it's utter nonsense for (the USGA) to even talk about this, much less work to determine if there is any evidence to say a 60-degree or higher loft offers any technical advantage that replaces skill.''

"This club requires more skill to hit consistently than any other wedge in the bag because when you have that much loft, there is a less friction between the ball and the face, and less compression of the ball against the face than any other wedge," Wishon said. "Thus, most golfers have a real problem finding that fine line between how hard to swing at the ball and how steep to hit down on the ball to be able to hit a 60-degree wedge solid enough to get the ball on the green and not leave it short in the hazard they were trying to finesse the ball over in the first place."

 

Star-divide

I'm inclined to agree with Wishon and Geoff.  (Was that in doubt?)

Here's why:

  1. The high lofted wedge requires skill - albeit a unique one to the game.  It only makes the game easier if a player can actually execute the shots well enough with the club in hand.  That's true for every club in the bag.  If someone is crazy enough to try an 80 degree wedge, have at it.
  2. This is just a diversion from talk about the golf ball.  I have said that I hope that the USGA uses its relatively peaceful implementation of grooves regulation would create precedent that would eventually lead to ball rollback.  The golf ball is a critical part of the combination.  It was not addressed as thoroughly as I had hoped with the grooves studies.  If the USGA continues to address clubs of different types, it tells me that they are still afraid of that Acushnet lawsuit they have been saving money up for these last years, per Frank Hannigan.
  3. The professional players gains exponentially more from equipment advances that the amateur.  The golf ball and club combination works optimally at swing speeds only matched by professionals and a very small group of amateurs.  99% of golfers don't see real, noticeable benefits from the modern golf ball and club.  Why take that 64 degree wedge out of their hand if they're not going to score better anyway?

I have been a proponent of bifucation of the equpiment rules of the game.  As far as I am concerned, if these rumors are true, it may be more worth the USGA's time to seriously explore two sets of equipment rules.

0 recs  |  Comment 5 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

left one out

there is still a 14 club limit. It doesn’t matter if someone puts an 89* wedge in their baq – if the next club back is a 56* sand wedge, that’s a huge hole in yardage and you can’t fill it with anything.

by the way – you can get a 74* wedge from Feel. It’s a silly club – but they make it and I’ve seen one person with one – and it is incredilbly hard to use.

"this ball will fit in that fairway"

by courtgolf on Dec 19, 2008 9:22 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

Is it that much of an issue?

How many Pelzites are there on Tour that actually carry 4 wedges to get one in their bag over 60 degrees? For most of the players, 60 degrees (or thereabouts) is as lofted as they go.

As for amateurs, many can’t do much with wedges in the 64-degree range because of the precision needed to hit a crisp shot with the low bounce/high loft combination. I suppose it’s a boost for low handicappers, though.

by Double Eagle on Dec 19, 2008 11:34 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

it's a mess

companies have been cheating on lofts for more than 25 years in their battle to be the “longest irons on the market”. It’s not uncommon to see a 45* PW in a set….which can make a 4 or even 5 iron difficult to hit for some people because of the lack of loft (and less spin on the ball).

That also leaves a huge gap between the PW and the standard 56* SW. (figure 2-4 yards per degree and you have a significant hole)

To fill in the gap, they make wedges starting around 48* and go up to 60* so people can fill in those huge holes in yardage left between their 45* “pitching wedge”, which used to be the 9 and even the 8 before the 80’s. So people carrying 4 wedges isn’t all that uncommon these days.

Pelz’ theories do hold water when you consider that more shots are hit from 100-120 yards an in than any other yardage – and for most people, that is wedge yardage.

He gets a little carried away, however, when he suggests building a set with a full swing club starting 40 yards out from the green and going back – so instead of learning to play different shots with the same club, you theoretically end up with 5 or 6 wedges in your bag, a putter, Driver, 3 and 5 woods and a few irons or hybrids.

Remember – the 60* wedge as a popular club is relatively new since the mid-80’s. Before that, people learned to hit different shots with their sand wedge, which usually has a lot of bounce. The 60* wedge usually has less bounce, so you get options based on ground, grass and/or sand conditions.

"this ball will fit in that fairway"

by courtgolf on Dec 19, 2008 1:19 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Oversimplified Pelz a Little

I think you oversimplified Pelz’s system quite a bit. He advocates 4 wedges with evenly spaced gaps going out from 30 or so yards to over 100 (3 grooved distances per club). you end up with a total of 12 evenly spaced yardages out to over 100 yards. None of those yardages is a truly full-swing yardage. His “clock” system has the longest finesse wedge swing at about 10:30.

On top of that, he covers things like bounce and turf conditions in his Short Game Bible, so it’s not like, “here’s 12 distances, you’re on your own to deal with reality.” or anything like that.

by Double Eagle on Dec 19, 2008 4:15 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

more recent than the "Bibles"

I’m talking about his more recent “suggestions” – since he has gotten into the club business. Now, the more wedges he sells, the better his bottom line is.

The Short Game and Putting Bibles are two of the best “self help” books for the short game – if you don’t have them – they are great to have around.

"this ball will fit in that fairway"

by courtgolf on Dec 21, 2008 3:04 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Waggle Room! Join our community! Have a golf story tip? Contact editor Ryan Ballengee and he will follow the story.
Start posting on Waggle Room »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Adam2_small
Golf Courses Are Running Out of Cash
Tiger_and_the_magic_club_small
The Dubai WC trophy - unfortunate symbolism
Cat_small
The Curse of Donald Trump?
Images_3_small
Who is Jay Williamson and Why is He in the Final Stage of Q-School?
Biggie-worldtrade_small
Robert Allenby Would Like Brian Gay to See the World
Cat_small
2010 LPGA Derangement Syndrome sufferer- Bill Huffman
Cat_small
I found another mistake in the golf record books
Cat_small
Jill Painter whines that LA doesn't have LPGA event in 2010 or the golf media's new meme
Cat_small
Steve Elling is jealous
Cat_small
Collision Course: LPGA and Champions Tour in Oregon on Same Week!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Golf News Net Shows

The 19th Hole Golf Show - 11/4 - We start the show by discussing the HSBC Champions and LPGA Mizuno Classic.  Then we talk with top 100 teacher Charlie King about how he plans to change golf instruction.  And, finally, we talk with legendary golfer Tom Watson about a host of subjects, including Turnberry.

Listen NOW on the Golf News Net Media Player!

The 19th Hole Golf Show on iTunes

GNN Newsmakers Feed

GNN MP3 Players

The 19th Hole Golf Show

Waggle Room Media

Facebook, Twitter, & Podcasts - Oh My!






Managers

Ryan2_small Ryan Ballengee